Sunday, July 24, 2011

Post # 7, Gee Chapters 3-4

Learning and Identiy



The cover for Arcanum

Gee opens chapter 3 by saying, "All learning in all semiotic domains requires taking on a new identity and forming bridges from one's old identities to the new one." (45). To that end, he writes of how he took on the virtual identity of a female half-elf named Bead-Bead in the game, Arcanum. Videogames like this promote identity work and reflection, a trait that would make modern schools much more successful. What makes these games such great tools for learning is that you basically put yourself in the role of someone else and have to successfully navigate the virtual world as this other person. It is a very good example of the aphorism, walk a mile in another man's shoes and you will truly know him (other variations say "before you criticize him"). While I've never played Arcanum, I have played a very similar game that Gee also mentions, Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. Oblivion is a game that so engrosses the player in its world that I can't think of a more apt name for it; I am figuratively oblivious to just about everything that's around me while I'm playing it, particularly time. But what makes a game like this so compelling is the multiple identities at work while playing it.

Gee speaks of three identities at play in a role playing game: virtual, real, and projective. As I play Oblivion, my three identities are part of what make the experience so rewarding for me. First, there is my virtual identity, Zion, a Breton who is by racial virtue, not only adept at magic, but resistant to it as well. Because I wanted Breton to be more versatile than the average mage, I split his class (skill set) between a mage and a knight. As such, Zion is proficient in magic and combat. The second identity, the real Antonio, lives vicariously through Zion. I am able to experience and do things as Zion that I could not in my real world. Finally, the third identity is something like a projection. This projection is what I expect Zion to do, how I imagine he should act and behave, and everything that I hope to accomplish with him (I've already accomplished a lot. Within this virtual world, I am not only the leader of the mages guild and the most powerful mage in the world, I am also the savior of the land, and the god of chaos, Sheogorath.) How is something like multiple identities good for learning? It allows students to take on various roles in their learning. By putting themselves in different roles--doctor, lawyer, scientist, etc.--there are better able to appropriate the knowledge a skill set of each role. They can also harness their pre-existing identies when learning, thus making the experience deeper and more rewarding.




In-game screenshots for a mage and knight in
Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. My character was, Zion,
was a hybrid of these two classes.

It is very important that a student identify with the role they are being asked to play within a semiotic domain. If a student does not identify with what they are being asked to be (i.e., a good student) then he or she will not strive to be what is asked of them. They have to have the desire in order to put forth the effort. One way that video games create this desire in players is the amplification of input principle. This is basically the principle that what ever effort is put into something becomes amplified in the results. With just a few pushes of some buttons, a gamer's effort is amplified in the corresponding actions of the character on the screen. Another way videogames create the desire to learn/play  in gamers is by operating within the player's regime of competence. In short, a goal must be difficult to achieve, yet rewarding. A student will not benefit from a teaching program that has easy goals, likewise, a program with goals that are too far outside the realm of a student's abilities will fail to produce the desired result.

Situated Meaning and Learning




When I was in high school I hated math. I particularly hated having to learn drawn out theorems in order to solve equations on tests. I have since avoided math to the best of my ability, so I'm not exactly sure on the particulars of these theorems, but I do remember that there was always a long way to get the answer my teacher was seeking and a shorter, easier way. Of course, she always insisted on the longer way. I always wanted to know why she cared which method I used as long as I got to the same conclusion (I also wished my teacher subscribed to Gee's "material intelligence principal" and would let me use my calculator on tests). When Gee points out in chapter 4 that good videogames allow for multiple ways of getting to the same goal, I could relate. Learning should also allow for multiple methods to get to the same goal.

Past experiences, says Gee, are what guide humans in how to proceed through new situations. When we learn, our thinking is rooted in embodied experiences. We can sometimes just use recall of a particular situation and apply it to a new one in order to deal with a new situation. Other times, however, we need to be able to adapt and modify our experiences in order to find the solution to a new problem. Gee spends the vast majority of chapter 4 talking about the game, Deus Ex, which requires using multiple routes, and experience, and adaptation to beat the game. In order to navigate through a game like Deus Ex gamers must first learn to deconstruct the meaning of the various signs within the game, likewise with learning, students must learn to take the various signs they are presented with and desconstruct them in a meaningful way. Finally, texts that students read are not only understood verbally. They are embodied in the students' experiences.

Questions:
1) Kids are often discouraged from having imaginary friends, but if we apply Gee's ideas on identity and learning, shouldn't they be incouraged to have imaginary friends, at least when younger?

2) Is Gee's "Material Intelligence" principle cheating?

3) If a student doesn't believe that he is capable of succeeding in a particular subject then he likely won't. I frequently made C's and D's in math class because I just didn't think I a mathematically capable student. To this very day, I feel incapable of doing anything but very basic arithmetic. If I were to suffer a head injury that caused me to forget how bad I am at math and had someone tell me that I was actually very talented at it, would I suddenly be better with numbers?

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Post # 6, Bogost Chapters 2-4

Bogost opens chapter 2 by referencing a game, BioChemFX, that is a first-responder simulation for various bioterror attacks conducted in an urban environment. The simulation is supposed to train someone the proper procedures for containing and/or mitigating the effects of a bioterrorist attack, and the responder then has decide whom to save based on a bird's eye view of the University of California, Berkeley landscape that shows a cloud of sarin gas spreading through the streets and campus. While the simulation may be good at giving the responder a working knowledge of HAZMAT protocols and an idea of how to handle a bioterrorist attack, that's really all the simulation can offer--an idea of how to react. Knowing the proper procedure to handle a disaster is no guarantee that the procedure will be carried out properly when the time is needed. Furthermore, even if the procedure is carried out exactly as planned there is still no guarantee of success. Deciding whom to save in such scenarios involves politics, and those politics can often lead to greater catastrophe. Bogost points to the failed evacuation of New Orleans during hurricane Katrina. There were safe guards and procedures in place for a sufficient evacuation of New Orleans and the surrounding area, but thousands of people died, nonetheless. In order for a simulation like BioChemFX to be more effective it needs to take into consideration politics and ideology. Bogost defines ideology as "hidden procedural systems that drive social, political, or cultural behavior..." (72). A videogame can provide greater insight and understanding of political systems and situations by exposing their procedural rhetorics.
Two HAMAT responders handling anthrax.

In chapter 3, Bogost continues his focus on ideology and politics by looking at ideological frames. Framing something that is real and factual in a particular way can yield results that may not have been the logical outcome. In other words, ideology and rhetoric can trump what is real. Speaking on the 2004 U.S. presidential election, Bogost mentions the political maps on websites and news stations that showed an apparent division in how different areas of the country voted, with the west coast, northeast, and Great Lakes sections of the country voting Democrat (blue), and the mid-west and south voting Republican (red). After the election was over and Bush emerged victorious, the two political parties attempted to frame the outcome of the election, with the Democrats coming to a realization that their rhetoric failed. As such, Democrats wanted to change their strategy by avoiding candidates from the northeast and having a stronger focus on domestic issues. However, while those things might have helped, the bigger change would come from effective ideological framing of reality. As Bogost says, "political success draws less from reality and more from representation." (99).

Videogames are not only good at exposing ideological process, they are also an effective tool to utilize if you want to recruit people to your cause or belief, or even if you just want to make a political statement just like many other forms of media. Both Democrats and Republicans have appropriated the various forms of media in our world--news channels and programs on TV, columns and stories in newspapers and magazines, documentaries (a common liberal outlet), internet sites like The Huffington Post, and talk radio (which is largely dominated by Republicans). Videogames, unlike documentaries and talk radio are not yet strongly aligned with one political ideology or the other. As such, videogames--like TV, printed media, and the internet--can reach people of either political inclination.
When CJ eats too much he becomes a Tubby-Thuggy

A political game need not deal with government politics, either. As an example, Bogost references Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas. In this game, which is set in a world meant to be a metaphor for Los Angeles, you play a gangbanger named CJ. In order to carry out his various missions, crimes, ho-beatings, etc., CJ must eat food. However, the only food available to him is fast food; if he eats too much, he becomes obese and less effective in his endeavors. Conversely, if he works out and exercises he becomes stronger and fitter. Someone who plays this game, then, could take from it many political meanings, from the dangers of high-fat diets, to the benefits of exercise, to the disparities in America between race and class. In chapter 4, Bogost mentions a number of games that move towards political ideologies. These games are effective because they allow the player to talk part in the procedural rhetoric of politics. But, as Bogost says, "political opinion itself is rarely black and white" (143). Political issues are often very complex and affected by various other political issues. Because of their ability to both express and allow players to experience those procedures, videogames can be an invaluable new addition to what Bogost calls a Digital Democracy.

Questions:
1) Bogost mentions the game September 12 as a game that effectively uses the rhetoric of failure because the game has no winning condition and even says so when you first start it up. While the game does employ rhetoric to show that USA's response to 9-11 is counterproductive, it doesn't offer a better solution. So, is the rhetoric of failure in this case an effective method of initiating change?

 2) Personally, I'm glad that videogames are mostly free of political rhetoric (the kind that involves our government) and think it would be a step back for the media if it did become highly politicized. Do you agree or disagree?

3) Politicians are fond of taking swipes at the gaming industry, blaming it for (among other things) high crime rates and children who go out and commit heinous acts. The few political games that Bogost cited notwithstanding, how likely do you think politicians are to try and tap into a genre that they've spent so long bashing?

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Post # 5, Bogost Chapter 1


The first chapter of Ian Bogost's book, Persuasive Games: the Expressive Power of Videogames, is launched by Bogost's extensive explication of the terms procedure and rhetoric, in order to familiarize the reader with his term procedural rhetoric. Procedure, he says, has a negative connotation in our society. It is often equated with bureaucracy, stifling laws, and bending to someone else's authority.  In other words, procedures are understood to structure our behaviors and actions, often seeming obsolete. In actuality, a procedure is really much more benign; it is merely a means of executing processes, and those processes are what define the way things work. Procedures, then, are much more helpful than we are wont to give them credit for. To illustrate this point, Bogost offers a scenario of a consumer who buys a DVD player that turns out to be defective. The consumer only discovers the DVD player is defective after the two week maximum on returns to the retailer has passed. In one part of this scenario, the consumer takes the defective DVD player back to the retailer and is engaged by a human customer service representative who--swayed by empathy, logic, or expediency--alters the procedure and allows the return. In the alternate scenario, the defective DVD player is purchased from an online retailer and the return process is handled by a computational program. The return is denied because it is handled by a computer, which is inflexible and incapable of empathy. The more important point that Bogost is trying to make with these two variations on the same scenario is not that you will get a different result for the same procedure depending upon whether you engage a person or a computer; instead, the more important point being made is that if it weren't for a (return) procedure, it might never even occur to the consumer that an unwanted or defective product could be returned to a retailer. Thus, procedures don't just limit behavior, they can also encourage it.

The term rhetoric, also carries negative connotations in our society. When people think of rhetoric, they may be inclined to think of corrupt businesses with spin-doctors who try to limn shady practices positively, or academics who use esoteric language to obfuscate what they're saying. Probably the most relevant example of negative rhetoric comes courtesy of American politicians who toss the word around as a way of denigrating their political rivals. But rhetoric has a very long history and was not originally seen the way that it tends to be today. Bogost states that, "Rhetoric in ancient Greece--and by extension classical rhetoric in general--meant public speaking for civic purposes." (15). Rhetoric was a very necessary skill for the ancient Greeks, particularly because they had to defend themselves in public courts; in this respect, I liken rhetoric to eloquence. But in the grander sense of the word, rhetoric is the skillful and effective use of communication. This communication can be oral, written, visual, and multimodal. As an undergrad, I double majored in English and Visual Arts. My art focus was graphic design. By the time I graduated in 2007, the art department changed the name of the focus from graphic design to visual communication. My coursework included learning typography, design principles, page layout programs, web design, and a number of other programs all for the purpose of creating effective and compelling communication: rhetoric.


Bogost uses the combined term procedural rhetoric to describe the practice of using processes persuasively. Persuasive games, he reasons, are "videogames that mount procedural rhetorics effectively." (46). It is not enough for a game to have compelling visual rhetoric, which is what most current-generation games focus. A truly persuasive game must have strong procedural rhetoric. In fact, it seems to me that Bogost believes that a game can be persuasive at the expense of being visually appealing, but that the converse may not also hold true. Bogost gives the game Tax Avoiders as an example of a game with unimpressive visual rhetoric but very strong procedural rhetoric. The game effectively employs process, in that it conveys at the very least a basic understanding of tax procedures.



Questions:

1) Do you agree with Bogost about the negative connotations behind the word procedure?

2) How can video games help remove the stigma associated with the word rhetoric?

3) If a game employs outstanding procedural rhetoric but lacks impressive visual graphics, how likely would you be to play it?

Monday, July 18, 2011

Post # 4, Gee Chapters 7-8

(In order to engage the class properly, I will be posting this blog out of chronological order.)



     The seventh chapter of Gee’s book, The Social Mind: How Do You Get Your Corpse Back After You’ve Died?, posits that learning is a social endeavor.  As an example, he tells the story of a young gamer named Adrian, who had logged countless hours into the game EverQuest, a massively multiplayer online role playing game (MMORPG) that predated World of WarCraft (although the Warcraft franchise technically existed first in the form of the game, WarCraft: Orcs and Humans). Adrian recounts to Gee how he and his online gaming clan went to a particular level in EQ called the Plane of Fear. Due to the extremely high difficulty of the challenges and enemies within this level of the game, there was a prerequisite that all of the player’s in-game avatars be at least level 45. Adrian’s character was level 46 before it ended up getting killed. In the process of dying in-game, Adrian’s character also lost 2 levels, dropping him down to level 44 and effectively booting him from the Plane of Fear. According to Adrian, 2 levels in EQ is equivalent to a time investment of 12 hours. Using the principles of social and distributed knowledge, Adrian’s character was revived and he regained his 12 hours of investment immediately. Adrian also uses his knowledge of the inner workings of EQ to modify the game, blog about the game, and create a database of shared information in order to help other players advance more quickly within the game. The argument here, I think, is that social learning trumps individual learning.



     Any tool (technology) and knowledge of one person becomes the tool/knowledge of another person within the same affinity group. We are already familiar with this concept when we think about a professor teaching his students. His knowledge then becomes their knowledge. After a point, the students can go on and become scholars in the same field as their professor. Likewise, if someone invests the time into developing a program that aids in research, that program then becomes a part of the collective knowledge of anyone else who learns how to utilize it. This is distributed knowledge. A perfect example of distributed knowledge is the internet, a tool billions of people use each day to access information that they may not already have within themselves. When the information is accessed by people who are outside of the intended audience or affinity group for the knowledge, it then becomes dispersed knowledge.  

     Extensive knowledge and intensive knowledge are integral to the cohesion of an affinity group. “Extensive” implies that an individual within the group is involved in many stages of the overall group goal. I liken this to being a jack of all trades within your particular group. “Intensive” implies that a person is a specialist in one or more areas, devoting a much more concentrated and focused effort into those realms of knowledge than in the extensive model. When Gee talks of the “jigsaw” method of teaching, it is essentially a method of intensive knowledge being distributed amongst a group. In this method, students are put into particular groups and given a subcategory of a class lesson to focus on. The groups learn their subcategories as deeply as they can and then the class reconvenes and each group teaches its subcategory of the lesson to the class.



     In the final chapter of the book, Gee stresses that he is not advocating the use of video games in education, but the learning principles of good video games. Furthermore, not everything that a person learns while playing a video game is necessarily “good,” but that is a moot point when we consider that “bad” knowledge and influences can come from any source of information. An effective teaching method should strive to be more like a good video game: it should encourage active and critical thinking, allow for performance before competence, and be challenging and rewarding at the same time.

Questions:
1) Gee states that the most important thing about thinking is not that it’s mental and happening inside of our heads, but that it’s social. Assume a person has been isolated from other humans for his entire life. Is his form of thinking inferior to those of us in society?

2) According to Gee, what we know to be right and wrong is based entirely on the influence of the people around us and the groups we belong to. To use a historical example, the citizens of Germany during the World Wars thought that their persecution of Jews was “right.” Assume that Germany had won WWII and gone on to dominate the entire world. Would the simple fact that the Nazi movement had a majority following still make their prejudices and ethnic-cleansings “right?”
 
3) I would argue that enough extensive knowledge can make up for a lack of intensive knowledge, but that the converse of this is not true. Do you agree or disagree?

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Post # 3, Gee Chapters 1-2

    In the Western world, we are indoctrinated into a system of learning (called the hermeneutic method) that is not inherently natural for us. We go to class, we sit in front of a teacher who presumably has all the knowledge that we are seeking and all the knowledge we are told that we need to have in order to successfully navigate our lives in Western society. In this model of learning, the students are empty vessels that need to be "filled" with the knowledge of the teacher and various assigned texts and educational supplements.

     We are then tested on our knowledge and discouraged to fail.  This method of learning relies heavily on reprimands in the form of bad grades.  To be a good student one has to make as few mistakes as possible.  Once we have been sufficiently filled with knowledge, we are then expected to go out into the real world and execute all the knowledge and theories that we've learned in class.  This system of learning is hopelessly impractical and outdated in today’s world where there is such a profound emphasis on technology and multiple streams of ever-changing information. 
     
     A much more natural method of learning is the heuristic learning method.  The basic premise of this method is that you cannot acquire the knowledge of how to do certain things simply by taking notes in class, reading a book, and then taking a test on all the knowledge you’ve just acquired. In the heuristic learning method, in order to learn how to do something you have to actually attempt it. In this method, failure is not punished, but rewarded. Learning how to play a video game is a heuristic learning method, and therefore, a much more natural learning process than what we are traditionally taught in Western schools. 

     One of the many aspects of video games that make them the tools for learning is that video games stress strategic thinking and problem solving.  Another aspect of video games that make them good learning tools is that video games can teach people how to think from multiple perspectives and to read through various lenses. Gee provides an example of the MMORPG game World of Warcraft. In his example, Gee points out that he played as three distinctly different character types. Each persona that he appropriated required that he modify his actions and behaviors in the game in order to succeed. Finally, video games, particularly the multi-player varieties, encourage collaborative learning. When the act of learning becomes a group activity, the experience often yields better results than going about it alone.


   Active learning does more to imprint knowledge on the minds of students. There is no substitution for experience, and video games are excellent at providing experience within their specific semiotic domains. A semiotic domain is, according to Gee:

…any set of practices that recruits one or more modalities (e.g., oral or written languages, images, equations, symbols, sounds, gestures, graphs, artifacts, etc.) to communicate distinctive types of meanings. (19)

If we take into account that video games are semiotic domains, then we must also naturally see that video games are a form of literacy and that the many symbols, graphs, and various other images within a video game compose part of that game’s language. This language is multimodal, by definition a text that combines both images and text. In order to successfully play a game (it is important to point out that for the purpose of this entire premise, the words “play” and “learn” are synonymous) one must become familiar with and adept at the game’s language. Most games that I am familiar with start off with a tutorial that walks you step by step through the basic functions and actions of the game. By imputing specific button sequences at the necessary and/or proper times, the player is engaging the game world. The very best video games, however, take things a step further by requiring that their players also employ critical learning.



     An excellent game that comes to mind when I think about critical thinking in video games is Metal Gear Solid 4 for the Playstation 3. MGS 4 is a thrillingly realistic, detailed, and difficult covert espionage first person shooter. What sets it apart from other first person shooters is that, while you can theoretically function in the game on the basics of “see enemy, shoot enemy, repeat,” you won’t even make it past the first level if you rely on just this active engagement. You must think critically. You must take into account your enemies’ locations, their firepower, and often a time limit. Add to this the fact that your go-to weapon is a tranquilizer gun and that you are much more likely to succeed in your mission if you remain undetected by the enemies, and you can see how critical thinking in games has the potential to be a great learning method. You must learn to operate in MGS 4 by its rules while also stepping outside of the box and figuring out various means to succeed. So, too, must you do in the semiotic domains of education and life.

Questions:
1)      1) Gee says that our experiences with other people is what determines how we read a text. Do you think this is mostly because of  or in spite of those other people?
2)    2) Would more people be inclined to look favorably on video games if they had more experience with instructional forms such as flight simulators or military simulations?
3)    3)  If your child’s school wanted to replace all text books with educational games instead, would you be for or against this and why?

Monday, July 11, 2011

Second Life Screenshot

I managed to take a snapshot of my avatar, but it didn't come out very well. My avatar is tall and slim with skinny jeans and an afro. In other words, it looks nothing like me. That's one of many frustrations I've had with Second Life thus far. The controls and interface for SL aren't very intuitive at all. I spent well over 45 minutes trying to make my avatar look more like I do before I finally gave up. Perhaps my internet connection isn't fast enough, or maybe I need a better graphics card, but it took many long moments for each place I visited to render, likewise for avatar customization. Hopefully, my experience will improve as I go along.

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Intro Blog

Hello All,

My name is Antonio Shaw and I am a second year graduate student in the MAE program at Clemson University. My focus is creative writing. I graduated from Francis Marion University in 2007 as a double major in English Literature and Visual Arts with a Graphic Design focus. I plan on applying to the RCID program this fall. In the event that I am accepted, my research will be on race and gender studies,  and visual studies and game theory. My ultimate goal in life at this point is to earn a PhD and become both a college professor and a published author. I'm very outspoken and gregarious. Aside from that, I'm pretty creative and have a wicked sense of humor. I'm the type of person that can find humor in just about anything.